Independent archive. Not affiliated with the original program, its host organization or its funder. Material is kept for reference and describes the program as it was when each page was written.

Disability Research Library Archive

Knowledge Translation: Introduction to Models, Strategies, and Measures

This literature review introduced knowledge translation (KT) for disability and rehabilitation research. It defined the term, compared several models that describe the process, reviewed evidence on which strategies change professional practice, and surveyed ways to measure whether research knowledge is actually used. The author drew mostly on health care fields outside rehabilitation and did not aim at a systematic review.

Definitions and characteristics

The term was coined by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research, which described it as exchange, synthesis and ethical application of knowledge through interaction between researchers and users. NIDRR and the Center later offered working definitions centered on improving the lives of people with disabilities. KT covers every step from creating knowledge to applying it. It is interactive, nonlinear, multidirectional, interdisciplinary, specific to users and context, and focused on impact. It builds on earlier ideas such as dissemination, technology transfer and knowledge utilization, and it grew alongside interest in evidence-based practice.

Models and frameworks

  • The CIHR model sets six opportunities for KT within the research cycle, from defining questions through to shaping later research.
  • The Understanding-User-Context framework poses questions about five domains: the user group, the issue, the research, the researcher-user relationship and dissemination strategies.
  • The Ottawa Model of Research Use links an evidence-based innovation, adopters, the practice environment, implementation, adoption and outcomes, with barrier assessment and monitoring throughout.
  • The Knowledge-to-Action framework pairs a knowledge-creation funnel with an action cycle that includes adapting knowledge locally, assessing barriers, monitoring use, evaluating impact and sustaining use.
  • The PARIHS framework predicts success from the strength of evidence, context and facilitation.
  • The Coordinated Implementation Model shows how community groups, administrators and policymakers jointly influence practice.
  • The Stetler Model guides an individual practitioner through five phases, from defining purpose and sources, through validating and judging fit, to implementing and evaluating.

Most of these models stress implementation more than knowledge creation.

Effectiveness of strategies

Overviews of systematic reviews found modest improvements overall. Passive dissemination, such as distributing materials, rarely changed practice, though it can raise awareness. Multifaceted approaches tended to work better than single ones, and outreach visits and reminders were more consistently effective. Audit and feedback varied widely, working best when baseline performance was low and the feedback was timely, individual and nonpunitive. Evidence for tailoring interventions to known barriers was inconclusive, and evidence on organizational structure changes was too weak to guide practice. Partnership-based approaches were described but not tested. Studies in rehabilitation were few, and several found that guideline publication or lectures produced little change, so no pattern could be drawn.

Measuring knowledge use

Research use can be instrumental (direct application), conceptual (changing understanding) or symbolic (supporting a position). Studies suggest each type has different predictors and should be measured separately. Use is rarely adopted wholesale, since people often adapt, partially apply or reject findings. One evaluation framework looks at goals, inputs, processes and outcomes. The review described many instruments:

  • Questionnaires counting specific research-related behaviors.
  • Stage-based scales, such as an eight-level Levels of Use Scale running from nonuse to renewal, and a ranked scale from rejection to adaptation.
  • Combined behavioral, cognitive and affective interviews.
  • Policy-focused measures of research influence.

The epilogue noted that applicability to rehabilitation remains uncertain and that more empirical work is needed.

About this summary: this page condenses a longer original publication and does not reproduce it.

This page is a summary. Related material is available from the content areas page.